New Jersey Homeowners Insurance

Data Snapshot: New Jersey Homeowners Insurance

New Jersey homeowners paid an average of $1,858 per year for home insurance based on U.S. Treasury FIO data covering 561 ZIP codes across the state. That is 5% above the national average of $1,776 per year reported by the Federal Insurance Office. New Jersey ranks 22nd most expensive out of 51 states and territories on annual premium, with ZIP-level observations ranging from $1,124 in 07034 to $8,535 in 07723.

Between 2018 and 2022, average premiums rose by 1.8% in New Jersey, placing the state 42nd nationally on five-year premium growth. The state-level loss ratio averaged 41.4%, meaning insurers retained a healthy margin after claims, typical of stable markets. Nonrenewal rates, the share of policies insurers decline to extend at expiration, averaged 0.85%, a climb of 48.4% over the study period (ranking 38th out of 50 states).

Within New Jersey, premium dispersion across ZIP codes is substantial: the most expensive ZIP (07723 in Deal) charges 659% more than the least expensive (07034 in Lake Hiawatha), reflecting local differences in catastrophe exposure, construction costs, and claims history. The FIO dataset aggregates voluntary reporting from the 40 largest homeowners insurers covering roughly 80% of the U.S. market, so ZIP-level figures represent market averages rather than individual quotes; actual premiums vary with dwelling value, deductible, coverage limits, and insurer-specific underwriting. This page is for educational research only and is not insurance advice, homeowners should obtain quotes from multiple licensed carriers or an independent agent before purchasing or renewing coverage.

How to read these figures: state averages on this page are computed from U.S. Treasury Federal Insurance Office data, which the office collects directly from the largest homeowners insurers and reports at the ZIP-code level. A statewide average blends expensive coastal and wildfire-exposed markets with lower-cost inland areas, so the figure is a useful benchmark but will understate what some residents pay and overstate what others pay. The loss ratio is the share of every premium dollar that insurers returned as claims; sustained ratios near or above one signal a market under pressure, where rate increases, tighter underwriting, or nonrenewals tend to follow. Claim frequency and nonrenewal rates show how often policies result in claims and how often insurers decline to renew, both of which track local catastrophe exposure. Treat the state number as context, then drill into your own ZIP code for the figure closest to your situation and compare quotes from several licensed carriers before deciding.